I used to raise goats. Had quite a few, 40+ at one point. Which in urban New Haven County Connecticut probably made me the biggest goat farmer in the county. I grew up in East Haven, CT. I am pretty sure they have laws banning the preservation of open space and farms. So basically I went from only having a fish, to the biggest goat farmer in the county overnight.
What happens to teachers who all of a sudden want to make the change from a traditional teacher driven traditional classroom to a more progressive project based technology integrated classroom?
When I first received my first set of twenty goats I can honestly say I did not have a clue. Sure I had read every book and internet article on raising goats but soon found that they did not prepare me for the real thing and all of the exceptions to the rules. As someone who was new there was great intimidation in directly contacting a more experienced farmer and admitting that I did had a problem, did not know what I was doing, and please help me out of a mess I had gotten myself into. For all of you out there brimming with confidence—well, maybe you don’t know what I am talking about. But how many people reading this have spent hours trying to figure something out with great frustration instead of contacting someone who would be able to help you with your problem and probably give you some great extra advice that you did not even know that you needed.
What helped me with the goats is I found goats911.com. It was a site that listed goat breeders, their specialty, and when they could be contacted for help. They invited people with problems to ask them questions. When I started with 2.0 stuff I found a lot of sites full of teachers looking for partners, or sites that offered places for people to ask questions, but these were usually sites set up for folks who were already a bit 2.0 savvy, or for folks who had edibility to go from 1.0 to 2.0 in 5 seconds. What exists for the people who are driving Pintos, who might need their hand held for their transition, for folks looking for or in need of a mentor…folks who are too intimidated to get into a 2.0 discussion on a race track full of Ferraris. I know that I had goats die, because I was struggling through things on my own just reading internet articles, and only dabbling in forums with the goat Ferraris. I know that for many teachers starting a PBL 2.0 classroom will result in death because of the lack of guidance. If you think otherwise, than either you are just smarter than the average teacher (which I will assume all of my readers are
or you have forgotten what it was like to make a jump to something brand new.
So I wish there was a teacher911.org(teacher911.com is already taken!). A place that had a list of teachers, their fortes, their email, Skype, twitter, something along those lines, that invited teachers who had zero experience to come and ask questions of an individual and could get close to an immediate response–a place to establish a relationship where mentors could be found. A place where newbies would not be embarrassed to ask the must simple questions of a person, and then come back and ask 10 more questions to the same person. I think newbies would be more likely to make a shift to 2.0 when they could ask questions and form a relationship with an individual rather than a ning, wikispace, or other type of forum. To get more teachers to make the shift to 2.0 we need to make a shift to 1:1 support.
Traditional professional development doesn’t work. I am talking about district supported, not when a person chooses to attend a conference. District PD is based on “we have something to give to you”, when a teacher chooses a conference to attend they go to that PD to “take something.” If you didn’t ask the question, you won’t remember the answer. One PD is full of people just getting info to questions they did not ask, the other is people seeking answers to their questions.
It bugs me when teachers say during parent conferences “S/he never asks questions in class, they need to ask more questions to catch up and do better.” It’s hard to ask a question when you don’t have the words, it’s hard to ask a question in a group that exposes a lack of knowledge, especially when it is in a group of people who have all the knowledge you are seeking. But maybe they would call teacher911 in the privacy of their home when they know the person on the other end is offering a safe helping outstretched hand.

You don’t think that Classroom2.0 is that space? When I visit, I see newbies in there all the time and they’re asking newbie questions, getting patient answers.
Or is that too much 2.0?
I also see Plurk as a nice developing ground for new folks too…where they can take their time and have real conversations. And I’m seeing newbies in there asking questions and getting answers from a couple of big-name ed-tech folks too!
Or are you talking more than just tech help. How to be SCHOOL 2.0 and not just tool2.0. Because if that’s the case, I know nothing out there for folks like that. The answers are too hard and for those who are trying, it’s really tough to clear ground for a building and give a tour of the site at the same time.
Very compassionate post, Paul.
I think this is a great idea. I agree that help is out there, but how does a newbie know where to go to find it? I’m pretty good at this stuff, but I didn’t even know about edubloggers until this year.
If the domain is available, I say snag it & start running with it. Let me know if I can help.
Thank you Paul. You just put into words all the things I’ve been feeling lately as I am going through an online course on Web 2.0. I’ve been so frustrated, yet I haven’t wanted to bother any of the people in my district with my questions. I know people’s time is valuable, and somehow I feel like I should be able to figure these things out. Right now I am the Pinto on the road with the Ferraris and therefore, due to my frustrations, I’ve skipped over a lot of great things I’m sure. You are also right on with your assessment of pd in school districts, but I tell you this…school districts have gotten and are becoming more and more RIGID each year. Instead of having more freedom to have project based learning, we are having less. We do not have access to most of the 2.0 tools on our school computers, for they have been blocked. Anyway, thank you for this blog post. It really hit home with me.
Paul, All of us are newbies about something when we start. Technology, web 2.0 tools, teaching students so that they are engaged and learning how to problem solve… does not come naturally to most teachers. That 1:1 relationship is a great way to really evoke the change that is needed in our schools. My principal asked for volunteers to have SMARTBoards to get put in their classrooms and as a condition of this technology she made each of these teachers be a mentor to two other teachers in the building. This worked out famously. The next year everyone had a SMARTBoard to use and were collaborating like never before. This example is just a small thing that could be adapted by any school that has the desire to empower their staff to use technology in ways that will change how we teach.
Thank you so much for your blog post. It has made me want to be an even better mentor to others in my school.
* Heidi Pence
http://hpence.blogspot.com
This is the tweet I just wrote before I read this post:
Currently reading @paulbogush ‘s entire blog- realizing I can’t do this. Not smart enough 2 b a math teacher! I have no clue what I’m doing!
As a first year teacher, I have nothing to fall back on. I want to have a classroom like what I think yours looks like but I have no idea where to begin. I have no experience to draw from and nothing to do if I can’t create something cool. I have never experienced the classroom I want to have. I don’t know anyone, maybe a few on Twitter, who has the math classroom I want. I can come up with all kinds of ideas for problem-based learning in social studies or english but not for math. Plus I’m afraid if I could create the problems, I wouldn’t know the right answer. When I think about how these math concepts relate to real life, sometimes I don’t know that they do. Why do I teach what I teach? I don’t even teach yet! Grr. I am a combination of terrified, clueless, and frustrated.